A local court in Fürstenwalde/Spree has issued a penalty order for defamation against André Thierig, the manager of Tesla's factory in Grünheide, the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung reported on 18 November 2026. The case goes back to February, when Thierig told the workforce that an official of the IG Metall union had secretly recorded a works council meeting on his laptop. An objection has been lodged, and Tesla says it wants the case tried.

What the court has done

Court Fürstenwalde/Spree local court (Amtsgericht)
Offence Üble Nachrede: a damaging factual claim about another person that cannot be proven true
Requested by Public prosecutor's office in Frankfurt (Oder)
Triggered by IG Metall's criminal complaint against Thierig, February 2026
Status Objection lodged; no trial date set
Fine Not disclosed

A penalty order, or Strafbefehl, is a written penalty that a German court can impose at a prosecutor's request without a hearing, usually a fine. If the accused does not object within two weeks, it has the force of a judgment. An objection turns it into an ordinary criminal case with a hearing before the same court, and until that case ends Thierig is presumed innocent.

"An objection has been lodged against the penalty order; no further procedural decisions have been taken yet," a court spokeswoman told the FAZ. Handelsblatt and the regional daily MOZ also reported the order. According to the FAZ, Thierig had earlier declined the option of closing the case in return for a payment, and he did not pay the fine.

How the dispute started

Shortly before the works council election in March, Thierig wrote to staff that the IG Metall official, instead of advising the council, "secretly recorded the meeting with his computer". Tesla filed a criminal complaint against the official, and the union filed one against Thierig, calling the accusation a "brazen and calculated lie". Both sides sought injunctions, and those proceedings ended in a settlement. Tesla could not later prove the claim, and a forensic report by the state criminal police office did not confirm it, the FAZ reported.

IG Metall clearly missed a majority in the March election.

What each side says

Tesla told the FAZ that the accusation was "unjustified" in its view, "which is why we have lodged an objection". "We are deliberately seeking a judicial clarification," the company said. It plans to use the proceedings to put all available information and facts on the table and will not comment further.

"It is now clear: criminal conduct by management was involved in the works council elections at Tesla," said Jan Otto, IG Metall's district head for Berlin, Brandenburg and Saxony. He called the order the first consequence of Thierig's attacks on union activity.

Why it reaches beyond one statement

Grünheide is Tesla's only car factory in Europe and builds the Model Y sold here. Thierig has fronted its expansion: this week Tesla said it would spend at least €3 billion on a new hall for the Cybercab, with production from 2029. Before the March vote he had warned that growing union influence could hurt Tesla's plans for the site. The plant still has no collective agreement, which IG Metall continues to demand.

For buyers, nothing changes. The case concerns what a manager told his staff, not production or the cars, and a trial date has not been set.