Germany's TÜV-Report 2027 ranks the Tesla Model Y last for the second year running. At their first roadworthiness inspection (Hauptuntersuchung, HU), after two to three years, 18.5% of Model Ys had significant or dangerous defects, up from 17.3% in last year's report. That puts the Model Y 109th of 109 models, and the TÜV-Verband says no model in this age class has posted a higher rate since the TÜV-Report 2015. The Model 3 is 107th with 12.5%.
The report, published with Auto Bild, covers about 9.7 million inspections at TÜV stations between 1 July 2025 and 30 June 2026. The average for two- to three-year-old cars is 6.4%; the best is the Mazda CX-60 at 2.3%.
Electric cars at both ends
The report now covers 26 electric models, up from 18. Four are in the top ten, led by the Mazda MX-30 in third place, but the bottom three places are electric too. Between the two Teslas sits the MG4, the first car from a Chinese maker in the report.
| Rank (of 109) | Model | Significant defects | Average mileage |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Mazda MX-30 e-Skyactiv | 3.0% | 26,000 km |
| 5 | Audi Q8 e-tron | 3.2% | 46,000 km |
| 16 | Hyundai Ioniq 5 | 4.2% | 45,000 km |
| 71 | Škoda Enyaq | 6.5% | 48,000 km |
| 83 | VW ID.4/ID.5 | 7.0% | 51,000 km |
| 107 | Tesla Model 3 | 12.5% | 55,000 km |
| 108 | MG4 | 16.0% | 37,000 km |
| 109 | Tesla Model Y | 18.5% | 58,000 km |
Source: TÜV-Verband results presentation, two- to three-year-old cars.
Suspension joints, brake discs and headlights
The Model Y's main weakness is its axle suspension: inspectors flagged worn ball joints and control-arm joints 24 times more often than on comparable cars. Brake-disc defects turned up on 3.4% of the cars, against 1.0% for the age class, and the front lights drew more complaints than average. The Model Ys had also covered more ground: 58,000 km on average, against 47,000 km for the class, according to the release.
The TÜV-Verband points to regenerative braking, which leaves the friction brakes idle so the discs corrode, and to the weight of electric cars. But it says the spread between models shows that design and component durability matter too, citing the Model Y's axle suspension and the MG4's brake discs (10.3% flagged). It advises EV drivers to use the brakes deliberately from time to time.
The Model 3 as it ages
The Model 3 is the only Tesla old enough for later inspections. Its rate rises from 12.5% at the first HU to 21.1% at the second, after four to five years, against a class average of 10.2%. The presentation lists 21.8% for that inspection and ranks the car 100th of 102. At the third HU, after six to seven years and 114,000 km on average, 27.9% of Model 3s failed: last of 91 models, against an average of 13.2%.
A Tesla has now been the last-placed two- to three-year-old car in three reports running: the Model 3 in the TÜV-Report 2025, at 14.2%, then the Model Y in 2026 and 2027. In Belgium, Flanders' first inspection barometer put both models last among four- to five-year-old cars earlier this month.
What it means for owners
This year's two- to three-year-old Model Ys predate the refreshed Model Y that went on sale in 2025, so the report says nothing yet about the current car. For owners of earlier cars, having the suspension joints and brake discs checked before the HU is the obvious precaution.
The TÜV-Verband also wants the inspection to change: electrical tests of the high-voltage system instead of a mainly visual battery check, independent battery-health tests, functional tests of driver-assistance systems and the right to check that a car runs approved software. "Manufacturers must not be the only ones deciding which information is available for the safety inspection," said its managing director, Joachim Bühler.