Euro NCAP published a new batch of ratings on 2 September 2026. Most coverage led with the same line — three Chinese models took five stars — which is true, and the less interesting half of it. The useful finding is which of the four pillars decided the results.
The scores
| Model | Rating | Safe Driving | Crash Avoidance | Crash Protection | Post-Crash Safety |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geely E2 | 5 stars | 79% | 72% | 86% | 95% |
| GAC Aion UT | 5 stars | 66% | 74% | 91% | 88% |
| Leapmotor B05 | 5 stars | 66% | 77% | 92% | 89% |
| CUPRA Raval, base spec | 4 stars | 58% | 66% | 91% | 95% |
| CUPRA Raval, Safety Pack | 5 stars | 72% | 77% | 91% | 95% |
The Kia K4 followed the Raval's pattern — four stars standard, five with an option pack — and the Mercedes-Benz CLE Coupé's Cabrio variant took five.
Crash protection is solved. The cabin is not.
Read the Crash Protection column downwards: 86% to 92%, a six-point spread across cars from three continents. Safe Driving runs from 58% to 79%, and it is the column that moved the Raval across the star boundary. The pack that did it — predictive adaptive cruise control plus front cross-traffic alert — lifted Safe Driving by 14 points and left Crash Protection untouched at 91%. In most European markets that pack is a country setting, and the Plus, Endurance and VZ versions clear five stars without it.
What Safe Driving scores
Part of the pillar is driver monitoring. The other part is where a car keeps its controls: under the 2026 protocol the indicators and hazard lights, the wipers, the horn and the SOS call must all be operable by direct physical input. Bury them in a nested touchscreen menu and the score falls.
- Geely E2 — "good use of physical controls for key driving commands and for the car's infotainment system", plus standard direct Child Presence Detection for extra marks. Best Safe Driving score of the round.
- GAC Aion UT — "relies too heavily on the centre screen for key driving controls". Speed-limit recognition accurate 68% of the time, and no Child Presence Detection.
- Leapmotor B05 — best Crash Protection of the set at 92%, but its comfort and infotainment controls "would benefit from greater use of physical switches".
Where Tesla stands
No Tesla has been rated under this protocol. The Model Y's five stars were published on 19 November 2025 under the previous scheme — Adult Occupant 91%, Child Occupant 93%, Vulnerable Road Users 86%, Safety Assist 92% — four categories with no equivalent of the Safe Driving pillar.
The pillar prices exactly the direction Tesla has taken its interiors, and the Cybercab is the clearest expression of it: manual driving controls entirely on the touchscreen, no steering wheel, no pedals, no switches. That car will not be rated in Europe. But when a European Tesla next is, Safe Driving is the first number to read.
What this means for European buyers
Chinese-built cars were 7% of EU new-car sales and nearly 10% of UK sales last year on Euro NCAP's own figures, and all three five-star cars here are aimed at European showrooms. "By actively embracing Euro NCAP's rigorous targets particularly this year, carmakers are showing they want to deliver safer vehicles for everyone on Europe's roads," said Dr Aled Williams, the programme's director.
The practical consequence is that a five-star badge from 2025 and one from 2026 are not the same claim. Everything rated before this year — the current Tesla range included — was scored without the Safe Driving pillar, so two cars can both advertise five stars while only one has been assessed on where it keeps its wiper switch.
The safety argument against Chinese EVs gets harder each round. The argument about screens now has a number attached.
Update: 2026-10-13
On 12 October 2026, Euro NCAP published its next round of 2026 results under the headline "Buttons are back for basic functions", and listed the driving-controls sub-scores for every car rated this year. The Audi Q7 scored 90% for driving controls: 100% for the essential tasks (indicators, wipers and washer, hazard lights, horn and the emergency call button) and 80% for comfort and infotainment. The Kia EV2 also scored highly. The XPeng X9, which keeps those functions on its central touchscreen, scored 20%. Across the cars rated under the 2026 protocol so far, the BMW iX3 scores 100%, the CUPRA Raval and Geely E2 80%, the Zeekr 7GT and GAC Aion UT 20% and the Leapmotor B05 0%.
| Model | Safe Driving | Crash Avoidance | Crash Protection | Post-Crash Safety |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audi Q7 | 72% | 77% | 88% | 100% |
| Kia EV2 | 74% | 66% | 86% | 89% |
| XPeng X9 | 57% | 82% | 91% | 91% |
All three took five stars. The X9's Safe Driving score of 57% is a point below the base CUPRA Raval that received four stars in September; Euro NCAP says the X9's five stars rest on Crash Avoidance and Post-Crash Safety, and that its speed-assistance system missed the benchmark on the 2000 km real-world European drive. "Our latest protocols reward the intelligent use of physical buttons and controls, as this can reduce driver distraction," said programme director Dr Aled Williams. "Other manufacturers, including XPENG, would do well to follow this strategy." Still no Tesla has been rated under the 2026 protocol.
Update: 2026-10-15
On 12 October 2026, Auto Express reported that Euro NCAP has "no plans to require manufacturers to fit physical buttons for climate control and media". A spokesperson said: "These are not time critical tasks under our criteria, and it is also not proven that direct physical input is safer." The physical-controls scoring described above therefore stays limited to the five essential functions: indicators, wipers and washers, hazard lights, horn and the eCall button. Comfort and infotainment placement counts only inside the driving-controls sub-score listed in the previous update, and Auto Express notes that this sub-score has had little effect on overall star ratings so far. For Tesla, whose Model 3 and Model Y keep climate and media on the centre screen, that is the part of the cabin Euro NCAP has said it will not score. Auto Express also records that Volkswagen's ID.3 Neo returned to physical climate toggles in response to customer feedback rather than to the protocol. Sources: No ban on car touchscreen climate controls, say safety experts, This is fine: Euro NCAP rules out ban on touchscreen climate controls.